The NCAA transfer portal is an alluring opportunity for college athletes seeking a fresh start, more playing time, or a chance at a higher level of competition. While the portal is often viewed as high-risk, high-reward, the reality is that many athletes experience high risk and no reward. Many athletes who enter the portal do not find a new home, leaving them with limited options and a potential end to their college career.
The Sobering Numbers
The sheer volume of athletes entering the portal is staggering, and the numbers don’t lie about the challenges they face.
- A Black Hole: According to recent data, as many as 55% of all college athletes who enter the transfer portal do not find a new school to play for at any level. This includes both scholarship and non-scholarship players across all divisions.
- Competition is Fierce: With thousands of athletes entering the portal each year, the competition for a limited number of spots is intense. A coach will often prioritize recruiting a transfer who is a known quantity with collegiate experience over an unproven high school recruit.
- Dropping Down a Level: Studies show that a significant portion of student-athletes who do successfully transfer end up moving down in competition level. The most recent data on college basketball showed that over 60% of transfers move to a lower competition level, and for many, this is the most viable path to a new team.
The Risks of Entering the Portal
For athletes, the portal can be a difficult experience, often resulting in unfulfilled promises, a loss of academic standing, and mental health challenges.
- Unfulfilled Promises: Athletes often enter the portal based on verbal assurances of more playing time, better opportunities, or even NIL money that may not materialize. Without a written agreement, these promises are difficult to enforce, leaving the athlete in a difficult position.
- Losing Academic Progress: Transferring between schools can be a major academic setback. Athletes often lose a significant portion of their credits in the process, which can delay their graduation by a year or more.
- Starting Over: The portal can be a difficult adjustment both on and off the field. Athletes must start over, from forming relationships with new teammates and coaches to learning a new campus and adjusting to a different team culture.
The Reality
Too many athletes end up in the transfer portal because they started the recruiting process late, didn’t have enough options to compare, or committed to a program that wasn’t the right fit. Even worse, many try to transfer without any college game video, making it nearly impossible to stand out to new coaches. The portal is not a quick fix.
The smartest move is to start early, build multiple opportunities, and make the right choice the first time. If you have a high school or advanced middle school athlete, get them evaluated now, be proactive. Or if your athlete is already on a college roster but has entered the transfer portal, NSR can provide the guidance and exposure they need to earn a true second chance, instead of getting lost in the black hole of the portal. Get your athlete evaluated today.
National Scouting Report is dedicated to finding scholarship opportunities for athletes who possess the talent, desire, and motivation to compete at the collegiate level. We’ve helped connect thousands of athletes with their perfect college.